Three genera have been defined with the same nominal type species, Ceriopora dichotoma Goldfuss, 1827. These are Tetrocycloecia, Grammascosoecia and Pseudoceriopora.
Canu (1919) introduced Tetrocycloecia. Canu, 1919 with the type species defined as "Ceriopora dichotoma Goldfuss, 1827 sensu Reuss, 1848". However, Canu was using French material, and this was likely not the same as Reuss' species. In 1920, Canu & Bassler corrected the name to Tretocycloecia, and the type species was listed as "Tretocycloecia (Heteropora) dichotoma Reuss , 1847, not Hagenow, 1851". (Hagenow did not introduce a new species, but identified the Goldfuss species as a new combination). The spelling Tretocycloecia is an unjustified emendation that has been rejected - see Nye, 1972. Canu & Bassler (1922) defined Grammascosoecia in the Family Ascosoeciidae, with the type species Grammascosoecia (Ceriopora) dichotoma Goldfuss, 1827 (Note the name in brackets is the original genus, not a subgeneric name). Material from the Maastrichtian of Holland was used in the revision of Goldfuss species: the Reuss reference was not used in the synonymy. This implies that Canu in 1919 was defining a new species Tetrocycloecia dichotoma Canu, 1919.
In 1972, Brood defined a new genus Pseudoceriopora in the family Pseudocerioporidae, with the type species Pseudoceriopora (Ceriopora) dichotoma Goldfuss, 1827. Brood included the following Remarks:
"CANU and BASSLER established a genus Grammascosoecia with Ceriopora dichotoma GOLDFUSS as genotype. Their description is however, incomplete. The important character according to CANU and BASSLER is the presence of a «median lamella» in the interior of the stems. However, no such lamella has been found in the material investigated by the present writer, nor was it found by VOIGT (1951) in an investigation of one hundred specimens. VOIGT'S opinion that Grammascosoecia dichotoma (CANU and BASSLER) must represent another species than Ceriopora dichotoma GOLDFUSS is fully supported by the present writer. If further studies will show, however, that Grammascosoecia dichotoma (CANU and BASSLER) is conspecific with Ceriopora dichotoma GOLDFUSS, Pseudoceriopora must be considered a junior synonym of Grammascosoecia" .
Brood was using "several hundred specimens", from the Santonian and Campanian of Malen and Ifö in Sweden, so it is uncertain that his material was similar to that of Hagenow.
The three genera have been defined using the same available name, apparently without study of the original material, or by defining a neotype. This is a taxonomic mess. These three genera presumably represent quite distinct concepts in the view of the authors, yet we still do not have a modern description for the species named by Hagenow (nor the material misidentified by Reuss). The strict interpretation of the Code of Zoological Nomenclature would make all three genera objective synonyms. It is permissible to define a new species by misidentification, but this should be accompanied by a complete revision using comparative material.
This genus includes the species:
(Canu, 1907) | Paleogene Oligocene | France | WoRMS 1414104 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1920) | Paleogene Paleocene Danian | USA Arkansas | WoRMS 1414105 | |
(Brood, 1981) | Oligocene-Miocene | Chile | WoRMS 1414106 | |
(von Hagenow, 1851) | Late Cretaceous Maastrichtian | Netherlands | WoRMS 1414107 | |
Voigt, 1962 | Late Cretaceous | Russia | WoRMS 1409284 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1926) | Early Cretaceous Aptian | England | WoRMS 1414108 | |
Canu, 1919 | Neogene Miocene Tortonian | Austria | WoRMS 1409285 | |
(Kühn, 1955) | Neogene Miocene Burdigalian | Austria | WoRMS 1414109 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1929) | Recent | West Pacific Philippines | WoRMS 472558 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1920) | Paleogene Eocene Priabonian | USA Mississippi | WoRMS 1414110 | |
(Kühn, 1955) | Neogene Miocene Burdigalian | Austria | WoRMS 1414111 | |
(Kühn, 1925) | Neogene Miocene Burdigalian | Austria | WoRMS 1414112 | |
(O'Donoghue & O'Donoghue, 1923) | Recent | Northeast Pacific Canada | WoRMS 472556 | |
Canu & Bassler, 1926 | Early Cretaceous Aptian | England | WoRMS 1409286 | |
(Busk, 1879) | Recent | South Pacific - New Zealand | WoRMS 573181 | |
(Taylor, Schembri & Cook, 1989) | Recent | South Pacific - New Zealand | WoRMS 573182 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1929) | Recent | West Pacific Philippines | WoRMS 472557 | |
(Waters, 1879) | Recent | Northeast Pacific Canada | WoRMS 472560 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1929) | Recent | West Pacific Philippines | WoRMS 472559 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1920) | Paleogene Eocene Priabonian | USA South Carolina | WoRMS 1414113 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1922) | Late Cretaceous Cenomanian | France | WoRMS 1414114 | |
(Brood, 1972) | Early Cretaceous | Sweden | WoRMS 1414115 | |
(Stoliczka, 1873) | Late Cretaceous Turonian | India | WoRMS 1414116 | |
(Canu & Bassler, 1926) | Cretaceous Maastrichtian | USA Tennessee, N.Carolina | WoRMS 1414117 | |
(Lonsdale, 1845) | Neogene Pliocene Zanclean | USA Virginia | WoRMS 1414118 | |
Taylor & McKinney, 2006 | Cretaceous Maastrichtian | USA Georgia, New Jersey | WoRMS 1409287 |
Tetrocycloecia magna at WoRMS.